Locking up the land has been a great way to concentrate wealth, and for a minority to dominate the majority. In England .28 percent of the population owns 64 percent of the land.

Privatization Leads to Hoarding

In the United States the top one percent of the population now owns more than the bottom 95 percent. The rest of us spend our entire lives working to pay rent or a mortgage making someone else wealthy. It’s time to end private property and give control back to the local community.

Private property gives people the incentive to hoard and not share what they have. When members of a community share what they have and produce, everyone else has a strong incentive to share as well.

We also won’t be able to develop the level of self-reliance needed to walk away from modern culture until private property ownership is replaced or circumvented. For instance, at today’s exorbitant real estate prices, it is almost impossibly to buy a small piece of land and make an agricultural living on it. You can’t pay for the cost of land today by jest selling vegetables—the model is broken.

Some have made the point to me that ranchers are important to keeping land as open space. I would agree with some of that, but note that ranch land is worked and therefore the soil and biodiversity are degraded. It would be better if people ate much less meat and ranch land was allowed to go back to the wild.

Ownership Leads to Despoiling

We know that the needs of the natural world are more important than the economic system, but privatization sees it the other way around. Privatization of land implies the right of the “owner” to use the land in anyway they see fit including despoiling the land to “make a profit” at the expense of the local community and all other species. Native communities know this and do not voluntarily give up the resources on which their communities depend until their communities have been destroyed.

Privatization has led to land use “for profit” and not “for community.” Our suburban system is at the heart of our economic problems and is the single greatest waste of resources in the history of the world—we are stuck with this infrastructure. Autos are only two percent efficient and transportation is almost two-thirds of total U.S. oil use. Private land development has led to a living arrangement that has no future.

Usufruct

Usufruct is a Roman term for the legal right to enjoying the replenishable fruits or profits from property owned by another. This includes the ability sell or let the enjoyment of the usufruct. But what if the owner was your local community? This would end private property.

In tribal communities usufruct means the land is owned in common by the tribe or community, but families and individuals have the right to use plots of land. Most native tribes owned land as a tribal group and not as individuals. The family never owned the land; they just farmed it. In a usufruct system, absentee ownership is not permitted. Modern usufruct examples include Cuba’s successful agricultural system, the traditional Mexico ejido system, and the right of native Canadian people to hunt and fish on Crown lands.

Cuba Urban Agriculture Success Story

Today more than 50 percent of the vegetable needs of Havana’s 2.2 million people is supplied by local urban agriculture. There are over 1,000 kiosks in Havana selling locally grown food. In smaller cities and towns the rate is between 80 to 100 percent. Farmers are now among the highest paid workers.

When the “special period” began in the early 90s, every vacant lot in the city was turned into a farm or a orchard. People cleaned up the land and started growing food. They just did it by trial and error. In 1993 the first Australian permaculturists came to Cuba to start the first train-the-trainer course. Today over 400 permaculture instructors have been trained in Cuba.

To increase food production the government worked with local farmers. The result was smaller farms and coops with a high degree of privatization and autonomy. Forty percent of large state farms were divided into privately owned cooperatives. Decision-making was localized with fewer regulations.

Tens of thousands of acres of land were leased rent and tax-free to small farmers. The only two requirements are that you grow food on the land and the land is delivered in usufruct. If however you stop growing food or another community need develops, you have to give the land back to the government. As a result, thousands of families moved to rural land with land rights guaranteed as long as you farmed.

Credit and service coops were expanded to allow small farmers to buy seed and rent equipment collectively, but also to allow the farmers to keep their land independently. This gives the benefits centralizing and yet being decentralized at the same time.

Some in the U.S. would dispute Cuban success. They say, “If we do not have 1,000 acre farms in Nebraska and Iowa run by eight wheel 375 horse tractors, we’ll all starve.” Give me a break. First, any permaculturist can tell you that a locally maintained polyculture out yields a monoculture by far. An individual crop within a polyculture will yield less, but when you stack multiple crops in the same space, polycultures out yield monocultures every day of the week. Second, breaking large absentee-owned farms into smaller family-sized plots creates jobs and builds local communities.

Community Land Trust

There is a way to start eating the private property monster from the inside out today—a land trust. Create a virtual patchwork community with you and your friends by contributing all or part of your land to a land trust for the benefit of the community and give yourself usufruct rights. The system won’t work though if they don't have the right and the capability to limit or stop newcomers from using it; overpopulation must be reversed. People are also more likely to stay in community long-term if you can offer a way to transfer usufruct to their children.

You can also get real estate tax-free non-profit status to lands open to the public for community service such as a church, an auditorium, or a conference center. You still have to pay real estate taxes on housing, gardens, and other properties not open to the public. Living on the property at the convenience of the employer enables a community to provide housing as compensation without paying employment taxes on the housing. Capitalize the savings on community infrastructure. Why should every household have a separate well, laundry, parking, and trash facility? Consult your local tax accountant for more information.

Landshare Registry, UK

End the Great Recession Overnight

You could solve the financial crisis overnight if we forgave mortgages and rent. You would have to pay your association dues and utilities of course. This would also eliminate the advantage of the “lucky spermer club.” Why should one inherent a free house while another struggles to pay rent for their entire lives just because of the advantage of birth?

Landlords would not be happy, but they could have a free apartment and wealth concentration needs to end anyway. A lot of large banks would go away; but deposits are insured, and the banks created the money for the mortgages out of thin air anyway, so what is the difference? The whole factional reserve banking system should go away, but that is an essay for another time. I would also add no more new construction in agricultural or open space. This would hopefully in-cent people to limit family sizes and overall population.

Seventh-Generation Zoning  Manipulated Solution

Living in a resort community, Telluride, CO, has taught me a lot about land use manipulation. It is too easy for private interests to manipulate government for their benefit through elections, committee assignments, lawyers, etc. What is zoned agricultural today can be a subdivision tomorrow regardless of what the master plan says by the vote of a handful of “public” officials. I would offer that land use zoning should only be modifiable after a popular vote of the seventh generation in a row has approved such a change in the community's and all species best interest. This raises the issue of reversing population growth as well. Otherwise a growing human population will want to develop more open and agricultural space. Holding all land in community usufruct also eliminates land speculation windfall profiteering.

Support Your Local Secession Movement

One way to speed up land reform may be to break up large nation states. I have advocated for some time now redrawing maps by watersheds and bioregions instead of squares or just one side of a river. The State of Jefferson and the Vermont Republic are two U.S. secessionist movements. Whether it is to fight corporate tyranny or recognize a unique geographical region, secession movements are growing as our modern culture collapses. One other point I frequently make is that hierarchies have great defenses to attacks from below, but they have none from abandonment.

Summary

Until private property ends, we will not be able to create the alternatives we need to enable people to walk away from modern culture. Of course we also need smaller families to reduce our numbers to have enough land to go around. Maybe as I said, we eat the private property monster from the inside out starting in areas where we an agree to let it go.

What is private property? Nothing actually. Private property is simply a social organization in which enough people agree to enforce the system of protection of land “owner” rights. The land knows nothing of ownership. Nature will sweep away our generation and its clinging to possessions like so many leaves blowing in the wind.

It is just cultural, artificial, and temporary. Private property is a house of cards. If enough people don’t go along with the system, the whole house of cards falls down. The glue that holds privatization together is fear. Locking up the food and property causes fear. “If you don’t follow our system and get a job, you don’t eat and you don’t get a home.” The bottom line, is to start building self-reliant communities so you are not dependent on modern cultural systems. Our culture has no defense against abandonment—learn how to walk away.

---

Visit www.culturequake.org to read the most updated version of this essay and to read the blog as a whole work, visit the Culturequake amazon.com book store, and learn more about the book Culturequake: The Fall of Modern Culture and the Rise of Earth Culture. Visit www.restorationfarm.org to learn what we are doing to grow new stories and cultures. ©2009 Chuck Burr LLC.

Notes:

Paul Hawken
Wild Earth, Fall, 2002

Energy Information Administration
Demand

Community Solutions
The Power of Community: How Cuba Survived Peak Oil

Equity Trust, Inc.
www.equitytrust.org

Evergreen Land Trust
www.evergreenlandtrust.org

Landshare
www.landshare.channel4.com

Institute for Community Economics
www.iceclt.org

National Community Land Trust Network
www.cltnetwork.org

Oregon Sustainable Agriculture Land Trust
www.osalt.org

Chuck Burr
Watershed vs. Bioregion: Get to Know Yours

Earth Rights Institute
Course on land Rights and Land Value Capture

The State of Jefferson
www.jeffersonstate.com

Second Vermont Republic
www.vermontrepublic.org

Vermont Commons
www.vtcommons.org

Josef Graf
The End of Real Estate